“Life of Pi” vs “The Odyssey” Comparative Essay Essay

Category: Organization,
Published: 25.11.2019 | Words: 2197 | Views: 560
Download now

Existence standed on the sea is very grueling and risky.

Just one or two are able to confront the demanding tasks on this situation using their wits and persistence. In the book Life Of Pi and the film The Odyssey, the journeys in the main characters are remarkably parallel, thinking about the works had been written over 20 centuries aside. Both of their particular journeys consist of stages like the archetypal hero journey, such as the Separation/Departure, Avertissement and The Come back. Although both equally Pi and Odysseus deal with extraordinary challenges, Pi’s personality is more interesting because through his first person narrative, the reader is attracted to his very sensitive nature, his vulnerability fantastic unique individuality while Odysseus is interesting because of the hero stereotype re represents.

Need help writing essays?
Free Essays
For only $5.90/page

Inside the Separation/Departure stage, both men are hesitant at first to start their journeys, but due to forces over and above their control, they go for phenomenal adventures for sea. For example, when Pi’s family reveals that they are going to Canada, Pi is definitely reluctant and want to leave. Professional indemnity shows his hesitation when he says “Why enter this kind of jungle of foreignness exactly where everything is definitely new, strange, and difficult? ” (Martel, 86). He was “thunderstruck” (Martel, 88) at the considered moving by simply also stating “It was like Timbuktu, by simply definition a place permanently significantly away” (Martel, 88).

Professional indemnity has created a familiar world of friends and family, filled with beliefs, his teachers and peacefulness, but has become crossing to a unknown terrain far away. Also, Odysseus would not want to leave for the Trojan viruses War when he would be going out of his family. He is known as to the challenge just after his son Telemachus was born, and he is hesitant.

Odysseus enjoys his family, even though he is seen as a typical brawny soldier. This shows that he would like to stay behind to care for his son and wife but non-etheless carried out his duty as they is a fearless soldier at heart. The similarity between all those two is that they both equally enjoyed your life at home, nevertheless had to start their travels due to political turmoil – For Professional indemnity it was Ghandi’s takeover of India that caused his family to leave, and for Odysseus it is the declaration of the Trojan Conflict. In the start of their journeys, Pi crosses the threshold when the Tsimtusm sinks, which forces him to get on a raft to start his adventure at ocean.

This can be found when Pi describes the sinking with the boat which in turn “…made a sound like a monstrous material burp” (Martel, 107). Pi also expresses his terror when he says, “Tell myself it’s a negative dream. Tell me it’s not really real. Tell me I’m nonetheless in my hoke on the Tsimtusm and I’m tossing and turning and soon I’ll wake up using this nightmare” (Martel, 107). This kind of shows the crossing in the threshold intended for Pi when he is the only human survivor who gets into this not familiar place.

This crossing coming from his familiar life to a much more hazardous one creates a struggle for him to come back to his normal world. Likewise, for Odysseus, he crosses the tolerance a few times and it begins after the Trojan viruses War when he angers Poseidon. This is noticed when he boasts that he defeated the Trojans by himself, thus angering Poseidon whom makes him suffer. His arrogance provides an impressive much more difficult journey home because Poseidon repeatedly delivers him away course preventing his return home for years.

Both personality cross the threshold in various ways, It really is forced after Pi although Odysseus brought it in himself. This really is considerably appropriate since Professional indemnity is innocent and did nothing to incur his fortune and the have difficulties that he had to withstand. However Odysseus’s crossing of the threshold is because of his ego which this individual has to shell out the price for promising about him self winning the war. In short, both personas were hesitant to get across the threshold, but in Pi’s case his situation appears more devastating as he remains to be young and has to bear together with the total lack of his friends and family.

Throughout their particular initiations, Professional indemnity and Odysseus must encounter many challenging trials on the road to survival and eventual reward. Pi’s primary trials would be the danger from the tiger as well as the overall risk of surviving from hunger, being thirsty and mother nature. With Richard Parker, Pi has to regularly find a way to train him, as he sometimes details: “Let the trumpets blare. Let the piles roll.

Let the show begin” (Martel, 182). This displays the importance of training to him. He will contact himself “THE PI PATEL, INDO-CANADIAN, TRANS-PACIFIC, FLOATING CIRCUUUUUSSSSSSSSSSSS! ” (Martel, 183).

Also in order to avoid starvation he or she must eat meats, as he recounts it the first time by stating “It was obviously a great breakthrough when I located that a fresh-tasting fluid could be sucked out not only in the eyes of larger seafood but likewise from their vertebrae” (Martel, 235). He identifies turtles while “…a plate of hot soup – became my favourite dish” (Martel 235). These quotations show Pi’s effort to teach the tiger and using his wits to outsmart him along with the finding of employing aquatic animals for various meats / food sources.

Back in Odysseus, After being heart-broken by Poseidon his quest back home consists of nothing but horrific trials including the Cyclops and Lotus predators. For example following Odysseus units sail Poseidon creates a fog causing them to meet a difficult foe, by simply trapping these people in the Cyclops’s cave. On the other hand Odysseus gets the Cyclop consumed and stabs him in the eyes, allowing them to break free. This shows his crafty bravery which will saves the majority of his guys and himself.

One likeness for the two character’s highway of tests is that they are all bigger than life. non-e of their issues are regular or even genuine. However Pi’s challenges are constant through the entire novel and there is no genuine relief or change of pace for him. Alternatively Odysseus’s bizarre challenges are constantly changing and creates an episodic storyline. Likewise he stands with many of his staff and designer watches them die during some of the people trials whilst Pi faces his difficulties alone. Various months later on, after Pi survive on the sea for 227 times he is compensated a chance for restoration at an wrack island prior to the final panel of his journey.

If he sees the heavenly island at first, he expresses that whenever he “…take in green, after a great deal blue, was like music to my eyes” (Martel, 285). Also when he eats saving money vegetation he comments “saliva forcefully leaked through… “I tore with the algae around me” (Martel, 288). After surviving around the sea to get so long, he is finally presented fresh food and water, permitting him to remain alive till he reaches mainland. Odysseus also obtains a break if he drifts along to Calypso’s island, after all the dangers he endures. There he can taken care of with a beautiful girl named Calypso and the lady gives Odysseus the rest and treatment this individual needs.

This shows that simply by overcoming all the challenges chucked at him, he is paid a chance to come out, even though Calypso intended to retain him presently there forever. The similarity right here between the two is that equally rewards present some kind of recovery, allowing them to have a breather just before arriving at their destination. Yet Pi’s incentive is generally small / significantly less satisfying compared to Odysseus because Odysseus nonetheless knows his family is back home while Pi still has to deal with the loss of every thing.

All in all, whilst Pi a new sustained and prolonged have a problem with the gambling and misery, Odysseus’s road of trial offers is more varied and fascinating to watch. The two heros would, however , have a rest close to the end. Each time a hero is definitely close to getting home, even though grateful to be alive, their return usually contains a single final process that he/she needs to finish.

Pi crosses the return threshold when he is found for the shore of Mexico and even though being helped by the local people, he tinges with the sadness of the loss in his gambling. He states that he can rescued when “…a part of my own varieties found me” (Martel, 316). Expressing his release by hell, this individual also says “I wept like a child” (Martel, 316). So although relieved being cared for, he can still grieving the loss of his family and Richard Parker. To get Odysseus’ bridging of the tolerance it arises when he comes home by simply boat, happily, with Athena changing his appearance to help him.

He is seen cheerful when reunited with his old friend (the goatkeeper) and his son Telemachus. However this individual finds out he has an additional obstacle to face in order to obtain happiness. Although he is content to be home, his delight is a bit decreased when wondering if his wife acquired kept their promise. He becomes quite angry angry and enthusiastic with what he sees in the village, definitely not the tranquil reunion he had hoped for together with his wife.

There is not much likeness between all their crossing with the return threshold except that they both go back on property, but Pi is very ill and worn out while Odysseus seem not. non-etheless Odysseus still has his family, when Pi’s is undoubtedly dead. Also Odysseus has another concern to face in the home while Pi has no physical challenge nevertheless must right now rebuild his entire life from scratch. After staying saved, Pi’s last little obstacle is in the hospital when interrogated by investigators from the sunken dispatch. As Pi describes his history, they issues his story by declaring “Mr.

Patel, we don’t believe in your story” (Martel, 324). Additionally, they says “It doesn’t hold up” (Martel, 324). Finally Pi says, “I know very well what you want.

You want a story that won’t surprise you” (Martel, 336). Because his adventure is really bizarre, unichip did not really accept it. But seeing that he had extremely vivid creativity, he accocunts for a completely new version in the journey to state to them and makes everybody satisfied. Back to Odysseus, when he arrives again at his homeland Ithika, he finds one more job which he directly confronts in conceal.

When he actually reaches back to his village, there may be many men creating chaos struggling with to make an impression on his better half. There is a match to determine the husband to be and he joins to end the madness. Odysseus has to embark on yet another struggle, first with just the contest by stringing his ribbon and bow and shoots an arrow with this into the twelve lined up wedding rings perfectly. After that he converts back into his normal do it yourself and eliminates all the suitors, ending the drama. Compareing both of their magic airline flight, it is a much tougher task for Odysseus as it is Physically more strenuous.

Pi’s last challenge can be minor and it causes us to wonder the validity of his entire journey. However he is still quite physically and mentally drained. Consequently , while Odysseus showed his physical capability once again Pi is obviously suffering in a more outstanding way filled with grief and future concern.

These two characters both revealed strong characteristics to complete their excursions, and while they will shared comparable stages there exists more compassion towards Professional indemnity due to his loss of chasteness. By analyzing the Separating, Initiation, and Departures, each of them include essential stages for the leading man to move upon. The general procedure seems to be the hero leaves his home to a new unfamiliar place, gains encounter / skill, and earnings home with boon or new expertise. With these said, although Pi and Odysseus’ adventures shared related plots, it is important to note that Pi is actually a single person surviving around the raft, without other companion pets other than the Royal Bengal tiger.

However Odysseus features his crew throughout several of his journey. It is usually argued that Pi had a tougher time at the ocean, but to always be fair Professional indemnity is only sixteen, whereas Odysseus is an adult stranded away wild for quite some time. His intrusions were fascinating and amusing but his personality experienced no depth.

Pi is more vulnerable and he draw out our shame. Because he is so clever, poetic and even hilarious at time, he is more pleasing to us throughout the extraordinary challenges.