Download now
When asked to find anything in the media that directly relates to material that had been reviewed in our mindset class there was a couple of topics that came to mind. However , one stands out to my opinion in particular, and that is a movie that we have seen lately called Steve Q. In this film Denzel Washington performs the position of David Q. Archibald, a man that will go to virtually any lengths to keep his only son, Michael, from declining.
During the video, John and his wife, Denise, learn that Michael comes with an enlarged center and needs an urgent situation transplant operation. On top of that, John has recently recently been reduced from full-time to part-time operate. He cannot afford the operation and his medical health insurance won’t cover it, thus he promises to do no matter what it will take to keep his child alive. This kind of obviously becomes an extremely tough moral decision that Archibald must make.
In the psychology textbook, there is much the same example to what occurred in film production company John Queen, this example was used by a psychologist named Kohlberg to conduct a moral thinking experiment.
The situation in the text speaks of a woman that may be near death with a special type of oral appliance of cancers, and there is only 1, recently developed drug that may possibly save her. Yet , the druggist was obviously charging ten-times what it expense to make the medication, which is 2000 dollars. Your ex husband attempted to get all the money this individual could however came up short, as well as the druggist refused to cut him a deal, and thus, leaving the person two selections, to possibly let his wife pass away, or grab the medicine. And like any good husband the person broke in the store and stole the drug intended for his better half.
This previously mentioned situation when described in class made me quickly think of the movie John Queen, and is the reason why this conventional paper is being crafted. In the film however , the victim was a child who may have barely skilled life but, and measures for his survival had been much more needy. Instead of a only a simple tablet or treatment this youngster needed a brand new heart, and a matching center with that, and without the proper insurance the transplant was close to impossible. So , John took the matter in his own hands. This individual felt that his only option should be to take the emergency room hostage until the doctors consent to give his son the operation that he desperately needs and locate him a compatible cardiovascular system. After fastening himself, his son and a handful of doctorsinto an operating room, the operation gets underway; however , a compatible heart still is yet to be found. Much of the time in this film is spent on the research for a compatible cardiovascular system, and also John’s communication while using media and police beyond the hospital enjoy it is some sort of settlement, when the truth is what this individual wants is a good your life for his son.
Approaching the end from the movie, a heart nonetheless cannot be identified. So David is around the verge of killing himself so that his son may live. Therefore he puts a single topic into his gun and puts the gun little by little toward his head. At this point in the movie, it is revealed that the whole time John was holding up the hospital with a great unloaded pistol. However , simply in the nick of time, a donor is located and John’s wife runs hysterically toward the hospital to ensure that equally her hubby and boy make it of that building alive. Eventually the cardiovascular system reaches the hospital and the small boy survives. John is definitely sentenced to something like 2 to 3 years in prison intended for holding the emergency room hostage.
The movie David Q shows to the audience in a very very clear fashion the system known as an ethical vignette, which was released in the 1980s by Kohlberg. As each of our class mentioned rather widely and the textbook touches on Kohlberg, was a famous psychologist in the early on 80’s. His studies were primarily aimed at moral reasoning, or the convinced that occurs as we consider correct and incorrect. Kohlberg likewise presents the thought of vignettes, or maybe a perplexing meaningful situation where something morally wrong must be done in order to do exactly what a particular person sees while right or mandatory.
Evidently in his exploration Kohlberg conducted an test where he asked people of numerous age groups to determine the morality of any situation, along with what they might do if they were from this persons place. And through the responses why these people provided, Kohlberg can tell just how well developed they were intellectually. Kohlberg identifies 3 periods of moral advancement in the textual content. They are preconventional morality, regular morality, and postconventional morality. Each of these phases are usually attained by certain ages however , many people may under no circumstances fully grow into postconventional values.
In conclusion, I believe in Steve Q, what John do was fully in his great families’ best interest, and is a perfect example of an ethical vignette. Ialso think that John thought on a very postconventional scale. He recognized what having been doing was morally wrong and against his ideals, however , because the insurance companies will be such bloodsuckers, he was left with no choice. However , he was looking out for the best pursuits of his family and himself and simply rejected to let his son perish. I think very few people are chuck into a condition as major as this kind of as quickly since John Queen was in film production company, however , it merely requires goes to show that there is no value for a human life and this hospitals merely shouldn’t refuse care to those who aren’t rich. I feel that what John do in this film was properly acceptable, and it performed out well in Hollywood however , in reality I think he would have been not able to single-handedly have a hold an entire emergency room hostage. But , it still remains to be a very obvious example of an ethical vignette. And is a great portal in the saying “desperate times call for desperate procedures.
1
