Use of electroshock therapy or anti depressants

Category: Wellness,
Published: 23.04.2020 | Words: 1651 | Views: 331
Download now

Sexual Dysfunction, Memory Reduction, Breastfeeding, Treatment

Excerpt by Term Conventional paper:


Need help writing essays?
Free Essays
For only $5.90/page
Order Now

Electroshock vs . Antidepressants

Make use of Electroshock Therapy vs . Antidepressants for Postpartum Psychosis

Literature on postpartum psychiatric diagnosis leans seriously toward planning to understand following birth depression, although talks little of following birth psychosis. The real reason for this appears to be that the depressive disorder diagnosis is more prevalent than psychosis. However , there have been enough reports of postpartum psychosis that it has become more of a regarded diagnosis. The majority of coverage of psychosis has been in media reports which demonstrate extreme serves of a mom who is using a psychotic break after giving birth. One particular case is Andrea Yates, a Tx mother whom drowned her young children.

Yates, the mom of five children aged eight years to six months, drowned all five of the children in 06 of 2001. She had been previously identified as having postpartum major depression and psychosis, and her husband was advised to never leave the children alone with her. A couple weeks prior to the drowning deaths, her husband began leaving your children with her for an hour every afternoon. The process of law originally convicted her with the deaths and sentenced her to life in prison, yet that decision was reversed about appeal. Yates was sentenced to spend period at a maximum secureness mental service, which was lately reduced to minimum protection.


To ensure the reader is aware of the intricacies of the primary terms employed in this analysis paper, explanations of some words and phrases are necessary. Although a definition of following birth psychosis have been difficult to effectively determine “It appears that in most cases, following birth psychosis signifies an show of zweipolig illness; the symptoms of puerperal psychosis many closely look like those of a rapidly growing manic (or mixed) episode” (MGH Middle for Women’s Mental Overall health, 2008). The treating the condition will probably be discussed within a later section, but the therapies themselves have to be defined also. Antidepressants can be found in several varieties (tri-cyclics, MAOIs, SSRIs and SNRIs), but they all act to defeat depressive symptoms by “inhibiting brain chemical breakdown as a primary system of action” (Keltner, 2002). Electroshock remedies are another possible treatment which has been used because the early part of the last century, but the practice has got much better after some time. Clinically referred to as electroconvulsive therapy (ECT), the practice “involves the inauguration ? introduction of a grand mal seizure, or bouillonnement, by moving electricity through the brain” (Frank, 2006). The efficacy of the treatment type will be reviewed later. An additional possible treatment for postpartum psychosis is to use a combination of the two therapies.


Of the two primary remedies, ECT or antidepressants, antidepressants are most often used because the procedure is thought to be safer compared to the alternative. Nevertheless , this is mostly when the medical diagnosis is following birth depression. Since there is no longer any danger for the baby of being dosed together with the mother (unless the mother is breasts feeding), various mothers who have experience the effects of postpartum despression symptoms are provided a regimen of antidepressants. Yet , this can be problematic since the side effects of a few antidepressants may be severe. MAOIs and tri-cyclics are rarely, when, administered today, but the miracle SSRIs are extremely common. Yet , even they may have some side effects such as possible insomnia, gastrointestinal distress and sexual disorder (Keltner, 2002). However , research has proven that antidepressants happen to be somewhat powerful in the take care of postpartum psychosis (Elin, 2011), but the effects are transitory and tiny.


Electroconvulsive therapy is an example of a treatment which has been controversial practically since it was first used. Inducing a general seizure when studies have proven that such an actions can cause multiple levels of long term damage (Breggin, 2007), would not seem to be a good idea. However , the practice provides proven effective when used to deal with depression and postpartum psychosis (Engqvist, ainsi que al., 2011). The primary side effect is partial permanent recollection loss which can digress toward symptoms of additional mental condition (Breggin, 2007). The fact the treatment might cause this type of destruction has caused it to be used occassionaly. It is only suggested when the depressive disorder is very severe and does not interact to other types of treatment, or in order to shows efficiency for different disorders just like postpartum psychosis (Fran, 2006). However , some have referred to as ECT the “penicillin of psychiatry” (Kragh, 2010) since it was once accustomed to a great degree. Because of the problems which have been delivered to light during research into their effectiveness vs . damage carried out, ECT is definitely not as pervasive as it was previously.


The most preferred choice of therapies is to use antidepressants in conjunction with antidepressants to treat depression and more extreme complaints such as postpartum psychosis (Science Daily, 2009). The most glaring issue with using ECT as a treatment for any disorder is that this causes memory space loss. A recently available study by Wake Forest School of drugs found that ECT, when used in combination with antidepressants, is a far more desirable treatment regimen. The head researcher explained “This getting could reduce one of the primary concerns about ECT – that this causes recollection loss” (Science Daily, 2009). ECT only has just a 70% to 80% response rate, yet most of all those patients still suffer a lot of memory reduction (Science Daily, 2009). The research found the fact that optimum treatment was to employ unilateral ECT (on 1 hemisphere with the brain only) in conjunction with an SSRI antidepressant (Effexor was more effective than an MAOI which was included as well in the study). Because of this efficacy with major depression the mixture has been examined with females diagnosed with postpartum psychosis as well.

Because any kind of psychosis presents differently than possibly severe depression, the same remedies are not generally indicated. Yet , doctors in Sweden executed a study in which the effectiveness of combined therapy was attempted. Previously, doctors had discovered that ECT was extremely effective for mothers with following birth depression, and it was treating choice “especially for mothers who were breastfeeding” (Engqvist, ainsi que al., 2011). However , for the reason that psychosis was considered a hazard to the child, breast feeding was usually not a problem. Mothers were first cared for using ECT in conjunction with a great antipsychotic, in that case, because “women with PPP [postpartum psychosis] show merged symptoms of mood and anxiousness disorders” (Engqvist, et al., 2011). This combination was proved to be the most effective, though the study had not been quantitative in nature which can bring its results in to question. The limitation is the fact self-report was your method of info gathering the less effective means of gathering info than a quantitative study.

Support of ECT

Many persons continue to support the use of ECT, especially medical personnel, mainly because they have viewed how successful it is as a treatment intended for severe psychiatric illness. There are many times when a patient encountered a lifestyle fraught with psychosis or perhaps severe depressive disorder and it includes either been mitigated or perhaps eliminated once ECT utilized. These studies have been recurrent enough that ECT offers continued to be a reason celebre amongst some psychiatric staffs.

Level of resistance to ECT

Unfortunately, for many who support the use of ECT independently, there are many more studies which will prove that the practice is definitely, at best, short-term. Patients who undergo an ECT treatment most often happen to be tasked with having bi-yearly maintenance amounts administered (Frank, 2006). Therefore the patient are not able to have just 1 ECT treatment. Professionals who also oppose the utilization of ECT as being a therapy have sufficient arguments against it ongoing use. Many point to the beginnings in the treatment as well as the myths that have been promulgated due to overanxious doctors (Kragh, 2010). Beside the perpetuation of misguided beliefs, there have been studies which marketed the placebo effect as a reason for the supposed recovery or the solid belief system of the patient. There’s even recently been legislation enacted in some says to stop the practice totally (Frank, 2006).


The most logical treatment for postpartum psychosis would be the one that provides proven to be the most efficient. However , as a result of limited exploration conducted on the issue that may be difficult to decide. The best way to observe what will function is to use the few research which advise an effective treatment, and infer from others.

Severe depression presents itself similarly to postpartum psychosis, so therapies that have been effective controls for severe depression would appear powerful for postpartum psychosis likewise (Gagne, ain al., 2000). Authors of several studies have observed the effectiveness of the combination treatment in treating psychotic symptoms which demonstrate themselves in patients who also are clinically determined to have severe depression (Gagne, ain al., 2000). However , this combination may also be positively affected by the addition of counseling that has proven its efficacy in several research studies (Hagen, Wong-Wylie, Pijl-Zeiber, 2010). It is advisable to conduct more studies in to the efficacy coming from all of these therapies because of the few that have been carried out in the past.

Because of the severe character of the condition, it would seem that more research may have been executed. However , since the diagnosis is rare, the