Download now
Excerpt from Annotated Bibliography:
According to Newman, healthcare professionals practicing in this particular theory get their own lives are enhanced and transformed (Neill, 2002). Her beliefs and consciousness-centered strategy were given birth to from her early nursing experiences concerning rehabilitation patients (Weingourt, 1998). She arrived at understand the changed connection between your concept of moment for her sufferers and their limited mobility. For most of her patients, your day would seem to drag along despite the fact that their rehabilitation periods were comparatively short. Her conclusion was that these individuals had an changed sense of reality. This eventually sparked her theory of Overall health as Growing Consciousness (HEC).
Looking at the practice of nursing by using a more spiritual lens, the HEC posits that there is a universal and expanding mind in which every humans participate – the healthy, the recuperating, plus the incurably ill. Newman thought this was an all-natural law as real because the law of gravity – an undetectable energy program that is frequently and unceasingly interacting with everyone and anything in characteristics (Vandemark, 2008). For Newman, nursing is definitely, at its primary, a process of recognition of where patients are in their intelligence, evidenced by the patterns that they demonstrate (Neill, 2002). Nursing staff must be capable to identify where a patient is on the procession of mind in relation to their physical environment. If mindful and imaginative, nurses will be better able to support patients increase their awareness level to boost their health insurance and abilities. Basically, nurses are able to use HEC to meet patients exactly where they are, aiding them use their personal power to conquer injury or perhaps disease through recovery or prevention.
You will find strengths and weaknesses to Newman’s HEC theory. It can be strong in this it embeds a sense of caring and thought for the person into medical inventions (Weingourt, 2008). Sufferers are seen in a very holistic way that extends further than their physical capabilities or perhaps limitations. For this reason, HEC can be viewed applicable to nearly any health setting and then for nearly every market. Critics, nevertheless , point out that the theory is extremely abstract (Vandemark, 2008). You will discover those who do not subscribe to metaphysics. For them, most of Newman’s concepts fall toned. In addition , understanding and learning when or perhaps how to interject caring in to practice can be misleading. Much of Newman’s ideas are simply qualitative. This means that the application of broadened consciousness is subjective with regards to the nurse applying the treatment (Neill, 2002). This means that outcomes may not be consistent across the board. This is confounded even further when you consider that sufferer environments and willingness to participate will likely vary. Rns must figure out HEC in a very deep level – beyond separated concepts – to realize their full rewards.
James Fowler – Beliefs Development
Adam Fowler’s concepts regarding hope development have been highly analyzed, debated, and critiqued for almost twenty years (James, 1997). The faith advancement theory as well as its associated levels expand the idea of what faith is. According to Fowler, all humans believe in something or someone (2004). The key of this perception is certainly not religious; alternatively it is the way we all make which means of the world through which we live – just one way of thinking and being and understanding fact (Jones, 2004). As Fowler himself identifies faith, it truly is:
the creating or interpreting of an supreme environment and as a way-of being in-relation to that. [it] must be seen as a central aspect of someone’s life alignment. Faith is a primary encouraging power in the journey of the self. It plays a central role in healthy diet the replies a person will make in and against the force-field of his or her your life. Faith, then, is a core element in a person’s character or personality (2004).
For Fowler, faith can be acknowledged as simple influential electrical power – a life-directing idea that guides us. He argues that the way people regard faith is through six distinct levels. Each is well guided by certain ways of staying. Progression involving the stages often results in trauma or inner conflict because people keep the familiar, alter their very own patterns of thinking, relating and discerning the world and settle in new ways of experiencing lifestyle (Fowler, 2004).
Stage you is considered the Intuitive-Projective stage which is most common in small children. It’s the stage at which basic thought forms regarding God are made based on lessons from parents or world at large (James, 1997). Level 2 is called Mythic-Literal and involves acknowledgement of broader ways of comprehending the world. School-age children enter into this level when they begin to ponder questions about faith and larger principles about your life. Stage a few, Synthetic-Conventional, is common for teenagers who move in differing social sectors and begin to form an all-encompassing belief program (Hart, 2008). This may could be reinforced by institutional religion and family custom. This is a stage various enter and not leave; it becomes the foundation of their world-view and they arrive to deny any contradictory beliefs or perhaps challenges via outsiders.
A lot of do break from Level 3 and enter a great Individuative-Reflective level which Fowler describes as “seeing beyond the box” and realizing that other boxes likewise exist (Fowler, 2004). This stage involves a desiring deeper meaning and a really personal asking yourself of religion, faith based leaders and authority, and definitions of truth. Fowler posits that stage is often notably nonreligious, and much more spiritual in characteristics. A critical study of former beliefs and, sometimes, disillusionment frequently occurs at Stage 4. Coincidentally, Stage a few thinkers believe that Stage 4 thinkers are lost or perhaps, in spiritual terms, backsliders. Fowler contends that Stage 4 persons have merely evolved within their attitudes and thoughts regarding faith and crafted fresh independent definitions for themselves (2004).
Stages your five and 6, Conjunctive Faith and Universalizing Faith correspondingly, refer a realization of the limits of logic and an acknowledgement of the paradoxes of life. Most people must reach mid-life before they will fully enter this stage (James, 1997). They come to appreciate the unknown of your life and the merits and benefit of before stages of religion. Faith by these periods is more community oriented and less focused on the individual. Fowler’s hypotheses were produced from hundreds of personal interviews jointly age group, but they have been met with criticism by simply other research workers who query empirical support for his claims and also his mixing of theology, education and psychological presumptions (Jones, 2004). Still, a large number of educators and religious specialists agree with the underlying suggestions behind Fowler’s work. It is used in pastoral counseling and education whilst in the psychology and nursing (Hart, 2008).
Summary
Margaret Newman and Wayne Fowler both equally focus their very own attention within the larger, more spiritual circumstance of man experience as well as the implication it has in a person’s healing. There are commonalities which exist between the philosophies of both theorists: individual reasoning, the ability to adopt to another’s point of view, social consciousness, and human formation of your world-view. Newman offers the nurse-patient relationship can be enhanced if it is viewed as a caring collaboration. HEC will not really pretend that to be a quick fix or direct nursing intervention; instead, this presents a chance to assist the sick by simply recognizing patterns and employing this intelligence to expand a patient’s awareness, self-care, and comfort (Awa Yamashita, 2008).
Fowler problems himself more with faith as a zoom lens through which we come across the world. His ideas regarding faith above the span of the lifetime may be particularly useful when working with older populations. More mature, Stage a few and 6 adults may begin to reincorporate earlier religious beliefs and traditions that were previously discarded (Fowler, 2004). This could be due to physical limits or also used as being a self-healing mechanism to avoid emotions of confusion or desertion. A health professional who is attentive can recognize this mature spirituality to be helpful to a patient attempting to find that means in his or her condition.
In amount, both theories/frameworks have implications for the practice of nursing. A theory, simply by definition, is known as a group of related concepts that propose actions that guidebook practice. Coming from Margaret Newman and
