Leadership scenario Essay

Category: Managing,
Published: 07.12.2019 | Words: 2441 | Views: 655
Download now

LAUNCH The purpose of the paper is to explore the different types of leadership variations that afflicted the determination of the employee. Jonathan and Dan have got two different managerial variations. Jonathan a manager in super market who also prefers to replace the duties of his subordinates. He is successful manager who is liked by his employees and everyone in supermarket wants to be employed by him.

Lalu a administrator who wants a successive routine and adherence with a focus on repeatability. He is pemandu for thirty minutes lunch break. The main heroes are two friends Alex and Stephanie. They operate full time and this job allows them to purchase college.

Need help writing essays?
Free Essays
For only $5.90/page

Alex works intended for Dan, he portrayed because unhappy and disappointed. Stephanie works intended for Jonathon and always ready to operate, she is strenuous and substantial motivated. This situatio A Question of Motivation will be examined through the Needs Objective Theory (Maslow), Equity Theory of Motivation, Hershey Blanchard Cycle Theory and Path-Goal Theory.

NEEDS GOAL THEORY (MASLOW) Maslow states that human beings have the five standard needs and theorizes that they may be set up in a structure of importance the buy in which individuals generally strive to satisfy them. (Certo&Certo, 2012, p. 371) Motivation provides a significant meaning in understanding subordinate’s behavior; determination can impact this habit to wealthy goals. Maslow’s Motivational theory is based on the idea that human behavior is controlled by using a limited number of developing fundamental needs which will operate within a fixed collection. Need is understood to be a condition of deficit.

People are perceived as a biological being having mental capacities. The psychological requires the needs which can be usually accepted as the starting point for determination theory are so-called emotional drivers. two The Maslow hierarchy of needs starts from the bottom with the pyramid. Very first step is _psychological needs_, these needs contain necessities just like food, sleep, water, sex drive, deep breathing, air.

These kinds of necessities required for body to outlive and usual function. Next step is _security needs, _ they contain security of family, health, human body, resources, real estate, employment, a safe work environment. Following is _social needs_, it provides the desire intended for social contact and conversation, friendship, family members, affection and other various types of support. Above social requires are _esteem needs_ which include status, acknowledgement, confidence, esteem of others. Because they are satisfied, person goes upper and stands on final need_- self-actualization needs. _ At this stage a person needs values, problem solving, creativeness, desire for success, personal development and growth.

The activity from one level to the next was termed pleasure progression simply by Maslow and it was presumed that over time individuals had been motivated to continually moves along upward through these amounts. In the case analyze, A Question of Motivation, Robbins and Judge 12th edition several levels happen to be demonstrated, for example, sense of safety Though pay isn’t great, it’s a steady job that permit them some flexibility, which will help when scheduling classes(Robbins & Judge, 2007, p. 712). It’s protection of having employment and protection of being in a position to pay for college. An example of interpersonal needs explained in initial paragraph, it states that Alex and Stephanie became friends since similar circumstance made these people closer to one another.

Their managers Dan and Jonathan happen to be differ in esteem needs, especially Dan is making Alex’s self-respect descend when it’s contrary for Stephanie. According to Robbins and Judge _A Question of Motivation, _ 12th release, Alex’s manager (Dan) supervises the create department and prefers intended for subordinates to work in similar position at all times, he generally humiliate Alex. Stephanie’s director (Jonathan) is very friendly, this individual encourages his subordinates to improve their intervalle by allowing creativity and working and working in distinct positions.

Stephanie is able to become challenge at the job that’s so why she is very confident, while Alex feels like grotty and useless since his director doesn’t let him show his abilities and do his ideal. Alex provides a low self-estimate because of one more worker who may be doing precisely the same job but she is a new worker and gets more cash than Alex. Stephanie’s director helps her to encounter self-actualization needs; he puts the trust in her and what she is doing.

When there is insufficient items, Jonathan enables his workers a chance to achieve jobs by ordering supplies She is heartened, this wounderful woman has high problem solving skills, likewise she can apply her imagination on producing new recipes. This every is the consequence of manager’s motivational and managing skills. FAIRNESS THEORY OF MOTIVATION Everybody seek for justness between what they put into job and what they get of it. Adams calls these advices and outputs.

According to Certo&Certo(2012) Equity theory discusses an individual’s perceived fairness of an work situation and finds that perceived inequities can lead to within behavior (p. 369). This kind of theory based on the social comparison process of examining the ratio of inputs and outcomes among oneself and a comparison additional, for example , persons compare themselves with others, and see what they benefit from job. The moment individuals aren’t treated quite when compared to their particular coworkers, they tend react in several ways, including changing their very own work habits to better obtain the advantages, resent coworkers and managing for the inequality or in extreme cases give up (Certo & Certo, 2012).

Inputs commonly include: perseverance, tolerance, hard work, loyalty, hard work, commitment, support of fellow workers and subordinates, ability, flexibility, personal scarifies, heart and soul. Results are typically financial rewards: pay, salary, expenses, bonus payment, travel, expansion, perks, curiosity, reputation, respect, praise and thanks, sense of achievement and advancement, campaign, stimulus. In the event individual seems that inputs are paid by outputs, then he is happy to work and even more motivated to stay inputting at the same level.

However , if individual feels that ratio of inputs to outputs is less beneficial compared to the ratio of others, then he becomes unmotivated to job and decreases typing. In this case A Question of Motivation, Robbins and Evaluate, 12th copy, there is a great unfair in Alex and Stephanie tasks. Stephanie contains a boss who also inspires and empowers her to make decisions and try to do her best, when Alex’s employer Dan appears to be stingy intended for praise and promotion, this individual holds his subordinates again.

That’s how come Stephanie adores her work but Alex doesn’t. Jonathan gives Stephanie opportunity to get rewards for good work. This provides you with her take great pride in for her task and inspiration to continue doing work at the same level. (Robbins and Judge, twelfth edition). Alex is unsatisfied with his task.

He becomes dispirit with job I don’t possibly care any longer. What’s the point? If I stock more oranges, or some thing meaningless that way, what does it get me-another sticker that says good job? ( Robbins and Judge, 12th edition, s. 713). Discouraged with Lalu and his administration styles this individual gives up changing the situation, nevertheless doesn’t quit because he requirements the job.

Alex doesn’t wish to have difficulty about fact that another staff has been working less time and is staying paid even more because your woman tells enhances to his manager. Alex and Stephanie work in the same place of employment, similar work schedule, nevertheless the feedback of this job differs from the others. My opinion that the type of motivation has just one side with great destination. While result, Stephanie is substantial motivated, whilst Alex is just working for salary without getting any skills.

THE HERSEY BLANCHARD LIFE CYCLE THEORY OF LEADERSHIP Management is a major way in which people change the brains (influence) more and move minds more and push organizations forward to reach determined goals. The Life Pattern Theory of Leadership can be described as rationale pertaining to linking styles with various scenarios to ensure successful leadership (Certo&Certo, 2012, g. 342). This kind of theory will be based upon the employee’s maturity and the ability to job without oversight. Also this kind of theory says that good leaders ought to change their very own leadership designs based on the maturity of the people they’re leading and the details of the work.

Leaders using this theory should be able to place basically emphasis on the job, and on the relationships together with the people they’re leading. In accordance to Certo&Certo, 2012, l. 342, you will find four different phases to the Life routine: High job Low relationships. In this phase workers first join an organization, they normally need course and require specific instructions in regards to what to do.

Staff must be knowledgeable about organizations procedures and procedures. The most appropriate procedure is a task-oriented leadership. Excessive task High relationships. A manager becomes even more familiar with subordinates and rely upon their overall performance. At this phase, followers might be willing to work with the task, but they still don’t have the skills to complete it efficiently.

Low activity High relationships. Market leaders focus more on the marriage and less upon direction. The leader works with they, and stocks and shares decision-making duties. As subordinates abilities and satisfaction become apparent and as encounter increases, subordinates seek more responsibility. However managers carry on and support and encourage subordinates.

Low activity Substantial relationships. At this phase subordinates are able to work with their own. They have high self assurance and skills. Leaders still oversee in progress but significantly less involved in making decisions situations.

This situatio study A Question of Motivation Robbins and Judge 12th copy is referred to two managers. Stephanie’s administrator Jonathan is usually portrayed while a 10-year veteran whom everyone generally admires for his friendly demeanor and relaxed supervision style which he often assigns his employees several duties each week so workers don’t acquire bored. Two years ago when Stephanie began working the girl had substantial task-low interactions phase. Through the years her maturity increased with this four phases. And now Stephanie merits Jonathan confidence to complete tough tasks with no total guidance The good thing is the fact I’ll have the ability to do this on my own, without someone breathing straight down my neck (Robbins & Judge, 12thed., p. 714).

It is seen that Alex doesn’t like Dan and he doesn’t respect him. They have hard relationship. When Alex was hired he had a high task-low relationship period and still without the movement.

Therefore , relationship and maturity get stuck. Dan’s attitude toward Alex is usually shown in lunchtime when Dan informed Alex: I thought that university students were supposed to be smarter than this. At the minimum I would feel that they may tell time.

I guess the university need to have glossed over you applications. (Robbins & Assess, 12thed., l. 714). It can be see that because of manager’s management level Stephanie and Alex receive distinct skills, nevertheless, working concurrently and placement. PATH-GOAL THEORY Path goal theory states which a manager can affect the performance and inspiration by offering rewards for reaching goals The path-goal theory of management suggests that the main activities of a leader are to make attractive and possible rewards offered to organization people who achieve organizational goals and to explain the kinds of behavior that must be performed to earn those rewards(Certo&Certo, 2012, p. 345).

So , this kind of theory depending on motivating subordinates to accomplish goals. The supervisor must use a style that best complies with the subordinate’s motivational demands. According to Certo&Certo (2012) there are several path-goal types of head behavior: SAVOIR The best gives certain guidance of performance to subordinates, for example, what to do, tips on how to perform job. SUPPORTIVE The leader is usually friendly and shows concern for the subordinates.

It can be most appropriate intended for situations in which tasks and relationships will be physically or perhaps psychologically demanding. PARTICIPATIVE The leader consults subordinates before making decisions and considers their particular suggestions. It’s most effective when ever subordinates are quite disciplined and involved in work. ACHIEVEMENT The leader puts challenging desired goals and expects subordinates to have dangerous performance.

In this instance study A Question of Motivation Robbins and Judge 12th Male impotence. It’s obviously seen that Jonathan uses the path-goal theory. He allows his subordinates to improve duties time to time. This style helps subordinates to learn every functional place in produce department, improves their productivity.

He collection a goal to Stephanie to market 10 wine bottles of truffle oil and if she achieves it, Jonathan will reward her which has a $75 reward. Jonathan is usually respected and well-liked, we all want to improve him, this individual created a setting and system that workers find equally interesting and challenging Most employees need to work for Jonathan, when he often designates his staff different tasks each week and so workers don’t get bored. (Robbins & Judge, twelfth Ed., g. 712). It could be seen that Alex’s manager Dan doesn’t use the path-goal theory. He doesn’t desire for participating and supporting his subordinates.

This individual doesn’t arranged some desired goals to achieve subordinates. So , Dan doesn’t change his behavior in just about any situation. REALIZATION To total my leadership scenario I’d like to inform that the most successful and greatest managers will be those who able to unite both motivational and leadership theories to accomplish goals of specific or business and aid the employee efficiency. The case analyze A Question of Motivation shows that the most appropriate characters to four ideas of inspiration and command are Stephanie and Jonathan.

Stephanie uses Needs Goal Theory (Maslow) and Equity Theory of Inspiration, she prospers in her job and very happy to be under Jonathan control. For Jonathan, this individual uses Hershey Blanchard Life-Cycle Theory and Path-Goal Theory. We can see that because of Dan’s low-level of command, Alex suffers and couldn’t do anything. So Dan should certainly learn a great deal by watching Jonathan in order to improve and increase his leadership style and habit.

REFERENCES 1) Certo, H. C., & Certo, S i9000. T. (2012). _Modern Supervision: Concepts and Skills. _ Upper Saddle River, NJ-NEW JERSEY: Pearson Education, Inc. 2) Maslow, A. H., 43, A theory of Human being Motivation, l. 372-396.

3) Carrell, Michael R. and Dittrich, David E., 78, Equity Theory: The The latest Literature, Methodological Considerations, and New Guidelines, p. 202-208.